Conflicting demands on a modern healthcare service: Can Rawlsian justice provide a guiding philosophy for the NHS and other socialised health services?

Published in


Fritz Z, Cox C. Conflicting demands on a modern healthcare service: Can Rawlsian justice provide a guiding philosophy for the NHS and other socialized health services?. Bioethics. 2019;00:1–8.

  • 19 March 2019


Why it matters

Healthcare systems face a number of challenges, but many of them boil down to competing demands. How do you weigh clinical needs versus financial constraints? Do you invest in current patients or plan for the future?

In situations of competing or conflicting priorities and interests, it’s difficult to design health system that balances everyone’s needs. But philosopher John Rawls’s theory of justice could help.

Rawls suggests that people will make rational, impartial decisions if they are separated from their vested interests. Behind a theoretical ‘veil of ignorance’, they don’t know what role they’re going to play in a society (or system). This frees them to design that system based on just and equitable principles.

This paper looks at how Rawls’ theory could apply to health system design. It asks what the NHS might look like if the people making policies didn’t know whether they were going to be a patient, clinician, or manager now or in the future.

Our approach

This analysis applies Rawls’ theory of justice to specific areas of conflict in healthcare, including staff training, work conditions, finances, and broader health policy. It explores how a Rawlsian approach could help design just and sustainable healthcare systems, and how it could help address some of the current challenges facing the NHS.

What we found

Read the article

Related content from our open-access series, Elements of Improving Quality and Safety in Healthcare

Operational Research Approaches

Reducing Overuse

Licensed under Creative Commons

These symbols show that the contents of this page are published under a Creative Commons licence called CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0.

It means that you’re free to reuse this work. In fact, we encourage it. We want our research to reach people who can help improve quality and safety in healthcare. But we do have a few rules:

  • Make sure you acknowledge The Healthcare Improvement Studies Institute (THIS Institute) as the creator and link back to this webpage.
  • You can’t sell this work for a fee, or use it for any activity that generates revenue without our permission.
  • Please don’t distribute a modified version to others without our permission.

You can read the fine print about the licence on the Creative Commons website. It’s meant to help us keep the integrity of our work and stay true to our values.

But ultimately we want our work to have impact. So if you’ve got a use in mind but you’re not sure it’s allowed, just ask us at